Anerica's test kitchen ... bleh

topic posted Sat, December 17, 2005 - 2:47 PM by  In a kind
Anyone lese find America's test kitchen underwhelming? Every time I catch it I find myself not agreeing or disbelieving their taste tests.
  • Re: Anerica's test kitchen ... bleh

    Mon, April 17, 2006 - 4:22 AM
    We don't have any real problem with it. It's just kinda dry. Remember, it's a group of college professors, not chefs.
    • Re: Anerica's test kitchen ... bleh

      Mon, April 17, 2006 - 8:29 AM
      Most of the taste tests have beenright ion the money for me. I like that theyare not swayed by the pretensious labels. I did my own taste test on Dark Chocolate and on Chicken Stock. The were right on the money. Cooks Illustrated is one of two cooking magazines that I subscribe to because they are so often correct and free of snobbery.
      • Re: Anerica's test kitchen ... bleh

        Mon, April 17, 2006 - 1:45 PM
        The magazine is also free of advertising. It's a real pleasure to have a quality cooking magazine that is purely content (and quality content at that).
        • Re: Anerica's test kitchen ... bleh

          Mon, April 17, 2006 - 2:20 PM
          Also, you can download pdf copies of old articles and reviews from their website! I don't subscribe, but I do tend ot buy a majority of the issues that come out each year! That and Saveur are the two food magazines I buy or subscribe to with regularity.
  • Re: Anerica's test kitchen ... bleh

    Wed, August 2, 2006 - 12:47 PM
    I find it rather dry as well. but useful. I have their book, Best Recipie.. i find it quite helpful and easy to follow.
    • Re: Anerica's test kitchen ... bleh

      Wed, August 2, 2006 - 5:32 PM
      I really like the fact that they pay attention to the budget-minded. I love their equipment tests--if there's a gadget that does the job not quite as well as the top-priced model, but for a lot less money, they will recommend the budget model. There are very few cook's resources left that won't sell out to the highest bidder, so I will maintain my subscription on that point alone.

Recent topics in "Good Eats"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
Snoozers Reserved 2 March 21, 2008
Items on Good Eats Reserved 5 January 27, 2008
New Alton fan Kelly 3 November 24, 2007
Feasting on Asphalt 2 0 September 9, 2007